This quest is obtained from the ghost of Samson who can be found in the basement of the Lighthouse West of the Cyseal West Waypoint Portal. He will tell you his story and about a women that you need to find to deliver a message.
- If you have the Cyseal West Waypoint, skip to step 3.
- Head West from the Cyseal North Waypoint Portal, through the archway. Keep North West and fight your way to the lighthouse.
- There is a miniboss from The Scaredy Pact quest you must deal with before you can enter the lighthouse. Shouldn't be too hard as long as you keep him neutralised and take out the Exploskeleton (and adjoining archers) early.
- Enter the basement and speak to Samson to acquire the quest. The quest will continue after you have defeated Pontius in Crabs Versus Skeletons.
- Pick up Pontius' key and head for the locked door south of the fight you witnessed between orcs and skeletons.
- Continue along the linear path and take out the miniboss. Proceed East past the boss and you will find a female ghost. Speak to her to update the quest for 1050 XP.
- Return to Cyseal lighthouse (use the West Waypoint Portal) and enter the basement.
- A dialogue will ensue in which you have to choose between +1 Compassionate or +1 Heartless. Either way you will earn 2100XP after they've finished talking and you can loot the skeleton.
- +1 Compassionate or +1 Heartless.