Evelyn, the apprentice healer that can be found in Thelyron's Healing House South of Cyseal Market, asks you to decide which one of her patients she should heal with her magic stone. She can heal only one of them while the other is doomed.
- Choose Steven, an older man with many grandchildren, for +1 Romantic.
- Choose Boris, a younger man with a knack for business, for +1 Pragmatic.
If you had not explored the scene of the crime in A Mysterious Murder prior to this, you will be teleported to the End of Time when you make your choice. If you'd already been to the End of Time, then making a choice here will unlock the Hall of Heroes room in your Homestead instead.
If you wait too long to make a choice, both men will die and the quest will fail.
- 600 XP from the quest
- 90 Exploration XP after Evelyn uses her stone
- +1 Romantic or +1 Pragmatic depending on whether you choose Steven or Boris.